My modpack with Botania installed crashes during startup of Minecraft

MagicFlowersss

Recently my modpack with Botania installed crashes during startup of Minecraft, It was working perfectly fine yesterday and now it kept getting crashes which it's so weird....

I tried deleted botania files from config folder in .minecraft but still crashes
My modpack started to load perfectly working fine when I removed Botania from my mods folder but my modpack continue to crashes more when I readded Botania back to my mods folder

Here's my crashlog report: https://pastebin.pl/view/a4fbf0cd

MagicFlowersss

Patchouli and Curios API are not affected it's the only Botania that crashes even more

This what look like I launch with only Patchouli and Curios without Botania it worked perfectly fine
https://i.imgur.com/wbhliwA.png

This what look like I launch with Botania
https://i.imgur.com/CQFzyZt.png

MagicFlowersss

I tried stuff

Updated my Java version to latest version
Using older version of Botania
Using recent older versions for Forge

but still crashes 🙁

Wormbo

Botania wasn't really tested with Forge 47.2.x. I know I got it to run with 47.2.16 at some point, but things are weird with Forge, which is why Botania's dependency is set to 47.1.3 and above. Can you try downgrading?

MagicFlowersss

Wormbo Tried downgraded my Forge version to 47.1.3 but it still crashes when i startup with Botania
Crash log report 2: https://pastebin.pl/view/3aa03e5b

Maybe my guess is that one of my mods could be incompatible with Botania installed on

MagicFlowersss

Both of crash logs

Forge 47.1.3
Caused by: java.lang.IncompatibleClassChangeError
at vazkii.botania.common.block.BotaniaBlocks.getFloatingFlower(BotaniaBlocks.java:1743) ~[Botania-1.20.1-443-FORGE.jar#243!/:1.20.1-443-FORGE] {re:mixin,re:classloading}

Forge 47.2.21
Caused by: java.lang.IncompatibleClassChangeError
at vazkii.botania.common.block.BotaniaBlocks.getFloatingFlower(BotaniaBlocks.java:1743) ~[Botania-1.20.1-443-FORGE.jar#244!/:1.20.1-443-FORGE] {re:mixin,re:classloading}

Both of this part of log shows same error even thought it's in different versions of Forge and Botania

MagicFlowersss

BTW i found issue when I removed all my other mods and leaving only Botania and it's APIs (patchouli and curios) it worked perfectly fine

It was one of my mods conflicting and causing Botania to crash, Imma going to examine which mod is causing Botania to crash

MagicFlowersss

UPDATE: it was Dye Depot mod that is crashing Botania,

Removed Dye Depot mod from my modpack and Botania finally started work perfectly fine but i don't want to remove Dye Depot i love this mod, please make compatibility with Botania

Wormbo

That sounds like an issue mainly on Dye Depot's side. A "IncompatibleClassChangeError" is the Java Virtual Machine's way of telling you that it attempted to load a class that depends on a different version of another class already present. In this case, it's likely that Botania depends on the vanilla state of the DyeColor enum, while Dye Depot modified that to include its additional colors, and that modification isn't binary-compatible somehow.

williewillus

Modifying an enum as core as DyeColor is certainly a choice....

Wormbo

Looking at their issue tracker, they seem to be crashing mods left and right with that. It's quite likely Dye Depot may need to create compatibility mixins for each and every mod that cares about dye colors on its blocks. The mod does an interesting thing on the outside, but its implementation approach will likely limit its use in mod packs.

unilock

I've mentioned Dye Depot's curious choice of implementation (via enum mixins) on their Discord guild, and unfortunately they seem pretty adamant about this being the only way to... do whatever it is they think they're doing.

The mod's primary developer stated they plan to fix every incompatible mod individually... more power to them, I guess.

williewillus

unilock I wonder what "fixing" each incompatible mod means.

Like, mixing into all of them? Or adding specific compat?

unilock

williewillus I have no idea. Honestly I'm not sure I want to know.

They posted a list to their Discord of over 20 mods they intend to add support for...